When Quentin Tarantino singles you out as an actor he “doesn’t care for,” it stings—even for someone as beloved as Matthew Lillard.
But the Scooby-Doo star has a powerful friend in his corner: James Gunn, co-CEO of DC Studios and director of the upcoming Superman film.
Gunn’s recent social media tribute to Lillard wasn’t just a coincidence—it was a masterclass in Hollywood loyalty.
Here’s why this moment matters, what Lillard said about the criticism, and how the two filmmakers’ friendship could shape the actor’s future in superhero cinema.
Tarantino’s Unexpected Criticism Cuts Deep
While discussing his 20 favorite films from the 21st century, Quentin Tarantino took an unexpected detour into actor criticism.
The legendary director didn’t hold back, calling Paul Dano “weak sauce,” an “uninteresting guy,” and the “weakest fu—ing actor in SAG.” He also dismissed Owen Wilson and Matthew Lillard with a blunt statement: “I don’t care for [Paul Dano], I don’t care for Owen Wilson, I don’t care for Matthew Lillard.”
For actors who’ve built respected careers, hearing this from one of Hollywood’s most influential voices hits differently than standard industry criticism.
James Gunn’s Perfectly Timed Show of Support
Shortly after Tarantino’s comments spread across entertainment media, James Gunn posted a photo collection on Threads featuring himself and Lillard through various years of their friendship.
Just a few photos over the years with one of my favorite guys (and actors), [Matthew Lillard]. No reason.
That “no reason” carries significant weight given the timing.
Gunn is known for championing actors he’s worked with, frequently casting them across multiple projects. His public defense of Lillard—however subtle—sends a message that resonates throughout Hollywood: loyalty matters, and talent isn’t defined by one director’s opinion.
How Lillard Processed The Public Criticism
Speaking candidly at GalaxyCon in Columbus, Ohio, Lillard opened up about the emotional impact of Tarantino’s words.
Quentin Tarantino this week said he didn’t like me as an actor. Eh, whatever. Who gives a sh—t.
But then he got real with his audience.
[Listen], the point is, it hurts your feelings. It f—ing sucks. And you wouldn’t say that to Tom Cruise. You wouldn’t say that to somebody who’s a top-line actor in Hollywood. I’m very popular in this room. I’m not very popular in Hollywood. Two totally different microcosms, right? And so, you know, it’s humbling, and it hurts.
Lillard’s honesty highlights an uncomfortable truth about Hollywood hierarchies. Criticism lands differently depending on where you stand in the industry’s complex social structure.
His vulnerability resonated with fans who appreciate actors willing to acknowledge their humanity rather than projecting invincibility.
Lillard’s Growing Presence in Superhero Universes
Despite Tarantino’s dismissal, Lillard’s career trajectory tells a different story—one of expanding opportunities in major franchises.
He’s set to debut in the Marvel Cinematic Universe through Daredevil: Born Again Season 2, playing a mysterious villain named Mr. Charles. That role premieres on Disney+ on March 4, 2026.
The DCU Door Remains Open
Lillard isn’t content with just one superhero universe. Speaking to MovieWeb in November 2025, he revealed his ongoing conversations with James Gunn about joining DC Studios’ projects.
He knows. I’ve called, I just did something with Marvel, and I’ve now entered the MCU. I literally texted him, I’m like, ‘If I do Marvel, am I still welcome to the DCU?’ He’s like, ‘Yes, totally, without a doubt.’
That exchange reveals the genuine friendship between director and actor—and Lillard’s enthusiasm for working with Gunn again.
I auditioned for Guardians of the Galaxy for Taser-Face. I just wanted to be in Guardians of the Galaxy so bad.
Why Gunn’s Loyalty Matters in Hollywood
James Gunn has built a reputation for working with familiar faces across projects. Michael Rooker, Nathan Fillion, and Jennifer Holland have all appeared in multiple Gunn productions.
This approach creates ensemble cohesion and rewards actors who bring professionalism and talent to set.
Lillard clearly fits this pattern. His praise for Gunn’s Superman film demonstrates mutual respect between collaborators.
I love that film so much. But look, all good things in time. My hope is that we find a moment to be together and work together again. I love everything he’s doing over at DC. Superman was a crowning achievement. That’s his love letter.
Lillard’s readiness to join Gunn’s DCU projects is clear.
I literally stand at the ready. […] ‘Put me in, coach.’ So we’ll see what happens in time.
What This Means For Actors Facing Public Criticism
Lillard’s experience—and Gunn’s response—offers valuable lessons about navigating criticism in entertainment:
- Acknowledge the hurt: Pretending criticism doesn’t sting often backfires. Lillard’s honest admission resonated more than defensive posturing would have.
- Value genuine relationships: Industry friendships built on mutual respect matter more than any single critic’s opinion.
- Focus on forward momentum: Rather than dwelling on negativity, Lillard emphasized upcoming projects and future possibilities.
- Recognize different audiences: Being “very popular in this room” versus “not very popular in Hollywood” acknowledges that success has multiple definitions.
Looking Ahead: Future Collaborations
James Gunn’s next film, Man of Tomorrow, arrives in theaters on July 9, 2027. Whether Matthew Lillard appears in that project or future DC Studios productions remains to be seen.
What’s certain is that Gunn values Lillard’s talent and friendship—a far more meaningful endorsement than any critic’s dismissal.
For actors navigating Hollywood’s unpredictable waters, having directors like Gunn in your corner makes all the difference. Loyalty, talent, and genuine connection often outweigh fleeting opinions from even the most celebrated voices.
Lillard’s journey from Tarantino’s criticism to potential DC Universe roles proves that one director’s “don’t care for” doesn’t define an entire career—especially when other powerful voices stand ready to say “you’re one of my favorite guys.”