“The Masked Singer” kicked off its patriotic celebration five months ahead of America’s 250th birthday, and the February 4 episode delivered plenty of surprises.
“Red, White & Clue Night” introduced viewers to a brand new wild card contestant while simultaneously unmasking a familiar face from reality television.
Season 14 continues to captivate audiences with its elaborate costumes and celebrity reveals, keeping both judges and viewers guessing week after week.
With ten mystery celebrities still competing, speculation runs rampant about who’s hiding beneath those larger-than-life disguises.
Calla Lily Wilts Under Pressure
Former “Real Housewives of Beverly Hills” star Teddi Mellencamp became the latest contestant eliminated from Season 14. Her identity was revealed after she performed John Mellencamp’s “Jack & Diane” — a song choice that proved to be her most obvious clue yet.
Jenny McCarthy called it correctly this time, despite Mellencamp stumping judges during her first appearance. The rocker’s daughter had been battling to keep her identity concealed, but familial connections proved too strong to ignore.
Mellencamp’s clue package referenced her melanoma diagnosis, which she’s been fighting since 2022. Her three children and recent separation from Edwin Arroyave in 2024 were also hinted at throughout her performances.
Pangolin Crashes The Party
Just when viewers thought they’d met every Season 14 contestant, producers threw in another curveball with wild card entry Pangolin.
I’m feeling very American right now, because I have no idea what a pangolin is.
Pangolin delivered an epic rendition of Alanis Morissette’s “Ironic” that had judges scratching their heads. Her clue package revealed she grew up in an area rich with American history where sports reign supreme.
Her football-obsessed father would quiz her on games and statistics growing up. After witnessing a halftime show with her high school boyfriend, she decided that’s what she wanted to do — despite his discouragement that led to their breakup.
She eventually became the “halftime queen,” proving passion and hard work triumph over doubt.
24 Karat Carrot’s Golden Identity
This New York City vegetable plays by rules now, but his past tells a different story. Bobby Brown appears to be hiding beneath 24 Karat Carrot’s costume, based on compelling evidence from clue packages.
The contestant admitted to being locked up at one point with no hope for a bright future.
I made a few bad judgment calls when I was younger, but now I’m living the golden life.
Brown’s multiple prison stints align perfectly with these admissions. His rise to fame with five-member boy band New Edition matches the five carrots shown as a bonus clue.
Perhaps most telling? That white bathrobe visual — an unmistakable reference to Brown’s infamous 1989 “My Prerogative” performance.
Eggplant’s Hot Sauce Success
Jack Wagner appears to be the celebrity behind Eggplant’s purple exterior. The “Melrose Place” star and recording artist received a personal invitation from Quincy Jones to attend the legendary “We Are the World” recording session.
During that historic moment, Michael Jackson allegedly told him something special.
I love your music. I love your voice. Keep doing your thing.
Wagner has appeared on Broadway multiple times, matching Eggplant’s theatrical credentials. His bonus clue — a bottle of hot sauce — referenced his success being “hot, hot, hot.”
Visual clues including a red swimsuit, police siren, and white dress all point toward Wagner’s extensive television career spanning five decades.
Galaxy Girl’s Meteoric Rise
Ashlee Simpson seems to be the star shining beneath Galaxy Girl’s cosmic costume. Her voice was recognizable from the premiere, though initial clues didn’t immediately confirm suspicions.
Week two provided stronger evidence when she recalled dramatically changing her look before a major shoot without telling anyone. Simpson’s transformation from blonde to black hair remains one of pop culture’s most memorable style moments.
Galaxy Girl described being accepted to top schools on scholarship and performing as the youngest on stage before she could drive. She walked away from perfection, spent years “lost in the background,” then worked relentlessly for her eventual breakthrough.
Visual clues included a New York Times bestselling book, golden surfboard, bowl of oranges, and jingle bells — all pointing toward Simpson’s career highlights and holiday music success.
High Voltage’s Revolutionary Spirit
Podcaster Theo Von emerges as the leading guess for High Voltage’s identity, despite judges overlooking him entirely. His clue package revealed his father emigrated to America with a passion for science while his mother is a poet.
Growing up, he experienced quintessential American culture.
Slurpees in the summer, Van Halen on repeat, MTV on full blast — and then, boom, we’re in the backyard spit roasting a goat for a family cookout.
Von’s father moved from Nicaragua to the United States, matching this backstory. His massive podcast audience reaches “billions” across the country, and he got his start on MTV — both referenced in clues.
The contestant emphasized being called “a patriot” and “a revolutionary” who’s “changing the fabric of American culture,” descriptions that fit Von’s cultural impact perfectly.
Previous Eliminations Reveal Star Power
Season 14 has already unmasked several notable celebrities. Disney Channel star Kylie Cantrall revealed herself as Cat Witch in the premiere, though judges remain unaware of her identity.
Todd and Julie Chrisley from “Chrisley Knows Best” were eliminated as the Croissants early in the competition. Todd didn’t hesitate throwing his wife under the bus for their lackluster performance.
There were two Croissants. I was pulled down. I was always laughing at Julie over sh*t that she was doing or tripping or bumping into things or whatever.
Tiffany Haddish emerged from the Koala costume as the third elimination, proudly announcing herself as a “late-night legend” and “one of the most influential people on the planet.”
Instagram personality Claudia Oshry (Girl With No Job) self-eliminated as Queen Corgi, while Taraji P. Henson was revealed as Scarab — an elimination many considered premature given her powerhouse vocals.
Rapper Tone Loc turned out to be Handyman, fooling viewers who were convinced he was Ice-T.
Remaining Contestants Keep Judges Guessing
Several mysterious performers continue competing with identities still concealed. Crane appears to be singer Normani, based on references to Fifth Harmony performing at the 2015 White House Easter Egg Roll and her ballet training.
Owl’s Southern twang and military references point toward Billy Ray Cyrus. His bonus clue mentioned participating in the Super Bowl with millions watching — Cyrus starred in a popular commercial during the 2020 game.
Pugcasso seems to be “American Idol” Season 11 winner Phillip Phillips. He worked at his family’s pawn shop before auditioning, and his biggest song “Home” aligns with the baseball home plate visual clue.
Snow Cone is almost certainly “The Hills” star Heidi Montag. Her 2010 debut album “Superficial,” Colorado roots, and marriage to Spencer Pratt all match up perfectly with clues.
Stingray appears to be Evan Ross, son of Diana Ross. His friendship with Paris Hilton, restaurant ownership, and marriage to Ashlee Simpson (likely Galaxy Girl) create compelling evidence.
With ten contestants remaining and eliminations happening weekly, Season 14 promises more shocking reveals ahead.