Former Bachelor contestant Cassie Randolph just said “I do” to musician Brighton Reinhardt in a stunning Costa Rica ceremony, proving sometimes the best love stories happen after reality TV cameras stop rolling.
The intimate destination wedding took place on December 5th at The Point Luxury Villa in Tamarindo, surrounded by 70 of their closest family and friends.
And the details? Absolutely breathtaking.
Randolph first captured America’s heart on Season 23 of The Bachelor with Colton Underwood back in 2019, but their 18-month romance wasn’t meant to last.
From Friendship to Forever
What many fans don’t know is that Randolph and Reinhardt actually met years before her Bachelor appearance. They started as friends and began dating in 2020, shortly after her split from Underwood.
Fast forward to their wedding weekend, and the couple chose a location with special meaning. They had visited the same Costa Rican villa during a previous vacation and fell in love with what they described as its “relaxed, go-with-the-flow Pura Vida spirit.”
Creating Core Memories
Before exchanging vows, Randolph shared with People magazine just how meaningful bringing everyone together truly was.
It feels so rare to get everyone to pause their lives, travel somewhere beautiful, and just be together.
The couple described the celebration as creating a new “core memory” with their “favorite people.” That intentionality showed in every carefully planned detail.
A Ceremony Full of Personal Touches
Randolph’s brother Landon and Reinhardt’s brother Cole co-officiated the ceremony, making the moment even more intimate and family-centered. Walking down the aisle on her father’s arm, Randolph glided toward her groom to the smooth sounds of Kenny G’s “Stranger on the Shore.”
The ceremony embraced local Costa Rican culture beautifully. A local man famous for walking around Tamarindo with his coconut cart was invited to open fresh coconuts and serve guests throughout the celebration.
White and pastel colors dominated the décor, while twinkle lights created what attendees described as “a warm, magical glow” as day transitioned into evening.
Two Stunning Looks for One Unforgettable Day
Randolph chose two gorgeous Pronovias gowns for her wedding day. For the ceremony, she wore the Ribelia design featuring:
- A dramatic long train
- An elegant open back
- A draped cowl neckline
She later changed into a Pronovias minidress for the reception, perfect for dancing the night away.
Her hair flowed in beachy waves, complementing an elevated “natural, clean-girl look” with her makeup. The overall aesthetic perfectly matched Costa Rica’s laid-back luxury vibe.
Vows, Dinner, and Dancing Under the Stars
After exchanging personal vows written from the heart, guests enjoyed a cocktail hour followed by a sunset reception that honored the moment’s magic.
Local caterers provided authentic Costa Rican cuisine, celebrating the country’s rich culinary traditions. When you travel somewhere for your wedding, why not immerse everyone in the culture?
The newlyweds shared their first dance to Etta James’ timeless classic “At Last”—a fitting choice for two people who found each other after years of friendship and personal growth.
Later in the evening, Reinhardt showcased his musical talents by performing his original song “Wherever We Are” for his new bride. A full band kept guests dancing well into the Costa Rican night.
Looking Toward Their Future Together
Now officially married, Randolph shared her excitement about what comes next with People magazine.
I can’t wait to start a family, create traditions of our own, and grow into the next versions of ourselves together.
Her journey from reality television heartbreak to finding lasting love proves that sometimes the cameras need to stop rolling before your real story begins.
Randolph and Reinhardt’s Costa Rican wedding wasn’t just about beautiful dresses and stunning sunsets. It represented something deeper—two people who started as friends, weathered life’s challenges separately and together, and chose to commit to building something authentic and lasting.
While Bachelor Nation may remember Cassie Randolph from Season 23, her real happily-ever-after is just beginning with Brighton Reinhardt by her side.